Writing my Odd Game

To Bootleg Boothill - pt.1

I want to run a game like Boot Hill and the Fear of Dice.

This will be a series of blogposts on how to achieve that.

In this first post, I will:


A Dream Campaign

To my surprise, in a recent question about what is your "dream campaign" in the Prismatic Waystation discord, "Boot Hill blogpost"-esque campaign was mentioned two other times besides my own answer.

Whatever type of campaign that post engaged with, it lingers in the collective unconscious as a object of desire.

It's no wonder. The BH Campaign is a masterclass in what a lot of GMs would like to achieve someday: a fully living and breathing town with a web of intrigue and problems, leading to an emergent campaign of constant consequence to and reactions to Players' actions? Complex rules for combat and complete diegetic decision making on all other fronts? That's the stuff.

Well, I wrote a system inspired by that exact post and campaign. Something with deep terrible violence and pain if you find the need to engage in combat to solve any conflict, but also with barely any rules to solve anything else, made precisely with the blogpost in mind.

So it is time to put it to test.1

Instead of guns of the wild west, this will be a medieval village, a land of God, social hierarchy, lords and serfs and farms and a more primal - aged - kind of sin.

Let's now write that campaign, and the village of Mosstone.


R&D

Before we begin proper, let's return to the source of our inspiration with an initial exercise: what makes the BH campaign special? What sort of tools allowed that campaign to exist, and what should we learn from the post in order to build our own?

To my dismay, the instant realization is that the campaign uses a lot of blorb to map itself. Considering blorb and I are not familiar friends, that will be our first challenge to eventually overcome.

Past that, there are many great advices and directions to follow.

First, this is a localized adventure, in a single place. It started with a bunch of named NPCs - hundreds! - and "nearly as many grudges". Then, it goes to draw from an actual true town, with a central tension, and continues to explore tension in everything else.

With that setup comes what I take as the two greatest advices for my copycat efforts: baking "violence, fear, greed, and vanity into every level of the region", and stretching tensions thin in every single situation.

The town of Tombstone was a barrel of explosives waiting for a flame, and on that cue, the Players got into it.

But we are not doing a wildwest game. This is a medieval village! Instead of rich barons of silver and oil and sheriffs and old churches, we have rich barons of lordship and lands and knights and old churches.

So we need to make a medieval village with numerous conflicts between its different factions, spice every single person with the medieval equivalent of the list of sins baked into BH NPCs, and hold everything together like a endgame jenga tower. Easy, right?

Then I have to do all this while sucking at blorbing.


Gamefying Blorb

This part of the post and of the system will be entirely unique for my own needs. I don't think anyone will find much use to it if they know how to do a blorb game, or how to draw out a network of relationships and factions in documents.

This is an instrument of necessity in order to help me achieve the sort of control over relationships and information this campaign will require.

I will use a deck of 52 cards + 2 jokers for controlling my NPCs.

I assigned a suit for each faction + one for the Land itself, following my own writing advice.

Then, I separated each faction into three subfactions: 2-4-6-8, 3-5-7-9, 10-J-Q-K and the Aces as wildcards for each Faction, unrestricted by the groupings.

I favored evens and odds because I have this idea of using the lower numbers to determine age/power/importance, and for some reason even/odds are easier for me to grasp at a glance and determine which subfaction that would be, instead of the possibly more logical 2345 6789 path.

So now, I have assigned each NPC an easy code!

Josh Rosco, 3 of Hearts - Hearts are the commonfolk from Mosstone, odds are the Ugly subfaction of the commonfolk - more on that below. I can know in an instant what are his major goals and his subfaction with a numerical structure assigned into easy codes I am already familiar with!

Take that, brain!

And you know what else can be done with a deck of cards?

The faction turns and developments based on what cards are drawn from the deck each session to determine the "random events" and progressions to occur!

Josh Rosco, the known rich trader from the mystical eastern lands? He found himself a suitor for marriage!

And you know what also works with cards? Matching combinations and numbers!

I intend to use something as simple as all the similar numbers having relationships with one another, but there is opportunity for stuff such as relationships with all numbers above/below too.

All this in attempt to help me remember the web of intrigues. Take that again, brain!


Chill out, Icarus

Here, a disclaimer. In order to add some complexity but to keep myself from going insane in a first attempt at this sort of campaign, I assigned each faction and subfaction with a Good-Bad-Ugly category, based by Mystic Arts's video on factions.

Is it a simplistic system? Well, yes. Could this be more complex and robust, such as Fedmar's Generating Intrigue Webs suggestions? Definitely.

But I ain't no mastermind here. We are dealing with a limited machine, folks. This pseudo-blorb 54 NPC social focus game is close to melting my wings in the sun already.

This is a project I intend to finish and run; perfect is the enemy of good.

Anyway.

Evens are Good, Faces are Bad, and Odds are Ugly.


The Factions of Mosstone

These are the factions and subfactions in their current state, based on the social division of medieval times of Bellatores, Oratores and Laboratores (the ones that fight, the ones that pray and the ones that labor):

♠️ HEAVENSWORTH BARONY

♦️ CHURCH OF SANTA SPERANDIA

♥️ FOLKS OF MOSSTONE

With the Heavensworth Barony, you have a shaken or recently disturbed Lordship; probably a recently deceased or so to be deceased decrepid Lord and a succession crisis of power, leaving space for bastards in the village and the Church to go after more power.

The Council will be the group of more direct governors, working for the actual benefit of Mosstone (and their own interest).

The Ugly Court will hold some amoral individuals, ready to take more power and expand their own influence; a less clearcut nobility to spice the group.

For the Church, I chose a fun saint to make an interesting jumostart of conflict: a woman saint known for feeding the poor and being a strong abbess will make for fun interactions between the genders in the church and village.

The high echelon of the church is easy fodder for a more evil and selfish subfaction, contrasted by the low ranks of more hopeful and earnest priests and nuns.

The scribes are a less predictable third group to throw in with their own ulterior motivations and understanding on what it means to be devoted to God.

Sorry, Knights, but you had to be relegated to the lower faction of the common folk of Mosstone for this all to fit. Amusingly, it did work well as the evil subfaction of that group, and not all wrong, made an interesting commentary on their position in the medieval society; albeit considered members of the lowest court, they were closer to serfdom and the common people than to the actual lords.

Add the serfs as our evens, and the freemen as our Ugly odds, and you have a logical and easy to embrace group of underdogs, and a selfinterested group of freemen working for the highest bidder.

Finally, the are 5 wildcards left: three Aces, which will be connected to each faction, and two jokers.


This will leave me with three tiers of complexity for each card/NPC.

FACTION
SUBFACTION
INDIVIDUAL

So let's create a deepening goal with each level.

First, the Faction Goal should be major. We have the Church, the Lords and the People, so for now we can have something as generic as "Expand the influence of God", "Empower the Court", and "Survive and Prosper", respectively.

Now, let's use the Subfactions to have different Methods for each; with the caveat Subfactions won't ever act against their Faction Goal!

HEAVENSWORTH BARONY
"Empower the Court..."

CHURCH OF SANTA SPERANDIA
"Expand the influence of God..."

FOLKS OF MOSSTONE
"Survive and Prosper..."

There! Some immediate power struggles already start showing. All Good subfactions have reason to work together, but Serfs might see the efforts of the Church as inconsequential if not carried by action. The low clergy won't have the means of action without the support of its leaders, but they may be more interested in taking space from the weakened baron family. A dying lord can raise concerns of bastards in the village, which could be a knowledge owned by the Scribes, as Knights are eager to find information and guarantee their future. The work of heretics also concern the Church, which means Freemen of science or women of power could be endangered, to the dismay of the High Abbess herself.

Many ideas, but! It is important not to forget the starting principles of the BH Campaign: keep folks viced and greedy - I wonder if my good subfactions will need to be worse.

And surely, we still have our third level of complexity, the Individual! Even if all Knights desire social ascension, how each of them individually will pursue it will go beyond Method, into their Ideals. One could hold "End justifies the Means" as an ideal, while a more devout one may think "God will reward my Faith".


What is next

One by one, I now have to create 54 individuals for Mosstone. I am considering the possibility of using a single card for an entire group (such as "The Servants of Heavensworth Castle") but that will definitely weaken my own capacity to maintain these collectives as individuals.

For example, the current structure allows me to have a total of 4 cards of Serfs, even though farmers were close to 90% of an entire medieval town. If each of them is a family, that could be easier to justify alwhile being easy to manage.

It remains to be seen.


  1. There are strong arguments for a system such as Violence, too. After all, it was also an inspiration for IRON on IRON, and it fits the same shoe Boot Hill does by focusing entirely on combat resolution. Deservedly, it also holds an immense amount of buzz surrounding it nowadays. A good, long term BH Campaign for Violence could make waves: most Violence scenarios are short, terse and scandalous, made for use of those short, terse and scandalous rules.↩